为什么RSAP参数模量不等于P和Q的乘积

本文关键字:不等于 RSAP 参数 为什么 | 更新日期: 2023-09-27 17:49:55

p和Q的值与.Net RSAP参数的模量值不匹配。根据RSA算法和MSDN文档,它应该是:P*Q=模数

我生成了一个512位RSA密钥对,并通过调用将其导出为XML

RSACryptoServiceProvider rsa = new RSACryptoServiceProvider(512);
rsa.ToXmlString(true);

这给了我以下XML:

<RSAKeyValue>
  <Modulus>rcLI1XTfmXtX05zq67d1wujnUvevBu8dZ5Q5uBUi2mKndH1FZLYCKrjFaDTB/mXW1l5C74YycVLS6msY2NNJYw==</Modulus>
  <Exponent>AQAB</Exponent>
  <P>1dwGkK5POlcGCjQ96Se5NSPu/hCm8F5EYwyqRpLVzgk=</P>
  <Q>0AAEMHBj7CP2XHfCG/RzGldw1GdsW13rTo3uEE9Dtws=</Q>
  <DP>PO4jMLV4/TYuElowCW235twGC3zTE0jIUzAYk2LiZ4E=</DP>
  <DQ>ELJ/o5fSHanBZCjk9zOHbezpDNQEmc0PT64LF1oVmIM=</DQ>
  <InverseQ>NyCDwTra3LiUin05ZCGkdKLwReFC9L8Zf01ZfYabSfQ=</InverseQ>
  <D>EWwFTPmx7aajULFcEJRNd2R4xSXWY8CX1ynSe7WK0BCH42wf/REOS9l8Oiyjf587BhGa3y8jGKhUD7fXANDxcQ==</D>
</RSAKeyValue>

现在我成功地编写了一个litte测试程序来加密、解密、签名和验证数据。

最后,我添加了一个小测试代码:

RSACryptoServiceProvider rsa = new RSACryptoServiceProvider(512);
rsa.FromXmlString(key); // key = string with XML above
RSAParameters param = rsa.ExportParameters(true);
BigInteger p = new BigInteger(param.P);
BigInteger q = new BigInteger(param.Q);
BigInteger n = new BigInteger(param.Modulus);
BigInteger myN = BigInteger.Multiply(p, q);
Console.WriteLine("n   = " + n.ToString());
Console.WriteLine("myN = " + myN.ToString());

这给了我们以下输出:

n   = 5200154866521200075264779234483365112866265806746380532891861717388028374942014660490111623133775661411009378522295439774347383363048751390839618325234349
myN = 23508802329434377088477386089844302414021121047189424894399694701810500376591071843028984420422297770783276119852460021668188142735325512873796040092944

为什么p和Q的乘积不等于模量?

我已经检查了很多东西,比如endian、encoding、BigInteger类,用上面的XML密钥成功加密、解密、签名、验证,但找不到任何解释为什么p和Q相乘不等于Modulus。。。

有人能帮我解释一下为什么p*Q不是模量吗?

可读格式的所有值:

Modulus  = 5200154866521200075264779234483365112866265806746380532891861717388028374942014660490111623133775661411009378522295439774347383363048751390839618325234349
Exponent = 65537
P  = 4436260148159638728185416185189716006279182659244174640493183003717504785621
Q  = 5299238895894527538601438806093945941831432623367272568173893997325464109264
DP = -57260184070162652127728137041376572684067529466727954512100856352006444159428
DQ = -56270397953566513533764063103154348713259844205844432469862161942601135050224
InverseQ = -5297700950752995201824767053303055736360972826004414985336436365496709603273
D = 5967761894604968266284398550464653556930604493620355473531132912985865955601309375321441883258487907574824598936524238049397825498463180877735939967118353

更新

根据答案,我为.Net BigInteger类编写了一个小的扩展方法,以正确使用RSAP参数:

public static class BigIntegerExtension
{
    public static BigInteger FromBase64(this BigInteger i, string base64)
    {
        byte[] p = Convert.FromBase64String(base64).Reverse().ToArray();
        if (p[p.Length - 1] > 127)
        {
            Array.Resize(ref p, p.Length + 1);
            p[p.Length - 1] = 0;
        }
       return new BigInteger(p);
    }
    public static BigInteger FromBigEndian(this BigInteger i, byte[] p)
    {
        p = p.Reverse().ToArray();
        if (p[p.Length - 1] > 127)
        {
            Array.Resize(ref p, p.Length + 1);
            p[p.Length - 1] = 0;
        }
        return new BigInteger(p);
    }
}

用法示例:

BigInteger modulus1 = new BigInteger().FromBase64("rcLI1XTfmXtX05zq67d1wujnUvevBu8dZ5Q5uBUi2mKndH1FZLYCKrjFaDTB/mXW1l5C74YycVLS6msY2NNJYw==");
BigInteger modulus2 = new BigInteger().FromBigEndian(param.Modulus);

希望这能帮助其他有同样问题的人:-(

为什么RSAP参数模量不等于P和Q的乘积

以下是我对您提供的XML参数的解析:

N = 9100595563660672087698322262735024483609782000266155222822537546670463733453350686171384417480667378838400923087358115007100900745853538273602044437940579
P = 96731388413554317303099785843734797692955743043844132225634400270674214374921
Q = 94081101418218318334927154927633016498744568046568114230258529096538660255499

正如你可以验证的那样,N确实等于p*Q。

您不能像现在这样使用BigInteger(byte[](构造函数,因为它希望字节数组是小端序的,而且Microsoft已经做了很多事情。相反,请颠倒字节的顺序。最后,因为字节数组应该是二进制补码,并且你的数字保证是正的,所以如果的高阶字节大于或等于128,你必须在数组的高位字节上加一个零字节。

BigInteger将数组解析为带符号的小端值。RSAParameters使用无符号big-endian。

所以i = new BigInteger(bytes.Reverse().Concat(new byte[]{0}).ToArray()))应该起作用。